Choice Home Warranty vs American Home Shield: the fine print
Last checked · How we check
Both start coverage after 30 days and both redo a failed repair within 30 days. Choice caps each covered item at $3,000 per 12 months; AHS caps the term at $50,000 with item limits such as $5,000 per HVAC system and $1,000 for a water heater. Choice excludes pre-existing problems known or unknown; AHS excludes known pre-existing breakdowns.
Side by side, with sources
| Item | What we found | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Waiting period — Choice | 30 days after the fee is received (sooner with proof of prior coverage and no lapse)What the source saysCOVERAGE STARTS 30 DAYS AFTER RECEIPT OF AGREEMENT FEE. YOUR COVERAGE MAY BEGIN BEFORE 30 DAYS IF WE RECEIVE PROOF OF PRIOR COVERAGE SHOWING NO LAPSE, THROUGH ANOTHER CARRIER. | choicehomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Waiting period — AHS | 30 days in the sample agreement (not for renewals)What the source saysInitial Coverage Waiting Period [30 days] [Not Applicable for Renewal Plans] | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 (sample homeowner plan agreement PDF, 2026) |
| Service fee — Choice | Per service request; the amount is on your Coverage Details page, not in the sample agreementWhat the source saysYou will pay a Service Fee in the amount set forth in Your Coverage Details to the Service Provider for each service request You submit to Us. | choicehomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Service fee — AHS | Per service request; you choose the amount when you buy; not refunded if the claim isn't coveredWhat the source saysYou will pay a Service Fee each time you place a service request. ... You get to choose your Service Fee amount when your purchase your home warranty plan. | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Coverage caps — Choice | $3,000 per covered item per 12 months (some items lower); items in one section share the limitWhat the source saysOur maximum liability is $3,000 per 12-month period for each Covered Item for access, diagnosis, and repair or Replacement. ... Coverage limit applies in the aggregate when multiple items are listed in the same numbered section. | choicehomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Coverage caps — AHS | $50,000 per term; HVAC up to $5,000 per system; water heater up to $1,000; appliances up to $2,000 eachWhat the source says$50,000 total limit per agreement term Up to $5,000 per covered HVAC system Up to $1,000 per covered water heater ... Up to $2,000 per covered appliance | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Pre-existing problems — Choice | Not covered, known or unknown; items must work on the start dateWhat the source saysmust be in proper working order on the effective date of this home warranty Agreement. Known or unknown pre-existing conditions are not covered. | choicehomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Pre-existing problems — AHS | Known pre-existing breakdowns excludedWhat the source saysM. Known Pre-existing Breakdown Exclusion. Other than Mismatched HVAC Systems, Breakdowns that existed prior to the Coverage Effective Date | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 (sample homeowner plan agreement PDF, 2026) |
| Cancellation — Choice | Any time; within 30 days, refund minus service costs; after that, pro rata minus service costsWhat the source saysYou may cancel this Agreement at any time for any reason. If You cancel within the first 30 days of the Order Date, We will refund the paid Agreement Fee less any Service Costs incurred by Us (unless prohibited by law). If You cancel at any time after the first 30 days from the Order Date: We will pay You a pro rata refund of the Agreement Fee paid for the unexpired term ... less any Service Costs incurred by Us | choicehomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Cancellation — AHS | Any time, by phone; effective immediatelyWhat the source saysYou may cancel your Plan Agreement at any time for any reason by contacting us via telephone. If you cancel this Plan Agreement, such cancellation will be effective immediately. | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 (sample homeowner plan agreement PDF, 2026) |
| Cash instead of repair — Choice | Choice may pay cash at its own cost, which may be less than retailWhat the source saysWe reserve the right to offer cash or cash equivalent in lieu of repair or Replacement in the amount of Our actual cost (which at times may be less than retail) to repair or Replace any Covered Item. | choicehomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Cash instead of repair — AHS | AHS may offer a cash-in-lieu payment; you have 30 days to decideWhat the source saysor offered you a Cash-in-Lieu Payment, you must inform us of your decision to proceed with the repair or replacement, or alternatively accept the Cashin-Lieu Payment, within thirty (30) days | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 (sample homeowner plan agreement PDF, 2026) |
| Repair fails again — Choice | Redone without a new service fee if it fails within 30 daysWhat the source saysIf work performed under this Agreement should fail within 30 days, We will correct the failure without a Service Fee. | choicehomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Repair fails again — AHS | A Pro comes back free if the repair has an issue within 30 daysWhat the source saysIf you have an issue with your completed repair within 30 days of service, we’ll send a Pro back out for free. | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
Common questions
Is Choice or AHS stricter on pre-existing conditions?
Choice's sample agreement excludes pre-existing problems whether known or unknown. AHS's sample excludes known pre-existing breakdowns.
Can you cancel Choice or AHS any time?
Yes, both allow cancellation at any time. Choice refunds minus service costs (pro rata after 30 days); AHS cancels by phone, effective immediately.
Related pages
- Choice Home Warranty: what the contract says
- American Home Shield: what the contract says
- Choice Home Warranty vs Select Home Warranty: contracts compared
- American Home Shield vs Select Home Warranty: the fine print
- Home warranty waiting period: when does coverage start?
- Do you pay the home warranty service fee if the claim is denied?
- Home warranty pre-existing condition exclusions explained
- Select Home Warranty: what the contract says