American Home Shield vs Select Home Warranty: the fine print
Last checked · How we check
Both make you wait 30 days and both keep the service fee when a claim is denied. AHS excludes known pre-existing breakdowns; Select excludes anything not working on the start date. AHS lets you cancel any time by phone; Select gives a full refund within 30 days only if no service was used, then pro rata minus a $75 fee.
Side by side, with sources
| Item | What we found | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Waiting period — AHS | 30 days in the sample agreement (not for renewals)What the source saysInitial Coverage Waiting Period [30 days] [Not Applicable for Renewal Plans] | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 (sample homeowner plan agreement PDF, 2026) |
| Waiting period — Select | Coverage begins 30 days after purchaseWhat the source saysCoverage under this Agreement begins thirty (30) days after the Purchase Date as indicated on Your Coverage Letter page (the “Effective Date”). | selecthomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Service fee — AHS | Per service request; you choose the amount when you buy; not refunded if the claim isn't coveredWhat the source saysYou will pay a Service Fee each time you place a service request. ... You get to choose your Service Fee amount when your purchase your home warranty plan. | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Service fee — Select | Charged per dispatch, even if the claim is denied, once the tech starts drivingWhat the source saysYou will be required to pay the Select Service Call Fee regardless of whether all or part of the claim is granted, excluded, limited or denied by Select. You will be required to pay the Select Service Call Fee once the Independent Service Technician begins traveling to Your home | selecthomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Fee if the claim is denied — AHS | Service fee is non-refundable even when the breakdown isn't coveredWhat the source saysThe non-refundable Service Fee is due and payable when you submit a Service Request. Please note, the Service Fee will not be refunded even if the Breakdown at issue is not covered by this Plan Agreement. | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 (sample homeowner plan agreement PDF, 2026) |
| Pre-existing problems — AHS | Known pre-existing breakdowns excludedWhat the source saysM. Known Pre-existing Breakdown Exclusion. Other than Mismatched HVAC Systems, Breakdowns that existed prior to the Coverage Effective Date | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 (sample homeowner plan agreement PDF, 2026) |
| Pre-existing problems — Select | Not covered; items must work on the start dateWhat the source saysAll systems and appliances must be in proper working order on the Effective Date of the warranty coverage ... Any pre-existing conditions or defects causing the malfunction of system or appliance during the term will not be covered by this Agreement. | selecthomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Cancellation — AHS | Any time, by phone; effective immediatelyWhat the source saysYou may cancel your Plan Agreement at any time for any reason by contacting us via telephone. If you cancel this Plan Agreement, such cancellation will be effective immediately. | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 (sample homeowner plan agreement PDF, 2026) |
| Cancellation — Select | Full refund within 30 days only if no service used; after that, pro rata minus a $75 fee and service costsWhat the source saysIn the event You cancel within the thirty (30) day period, the You shall be entitled to a full refund if and only if, no service has been provided under the contract. After the thirtieth day, You may receive a refund pro-rated at the non-discounted annual plan cost. A seventy-five dollar ($75) cancellation fee will be charged and any service costs incurred by Select not to exceed the cost of the contract. | selecthomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
| Cash instead of repair — AHS | AHS may offer a cash-in-lieu payment; you have 30 days to decideWhat the source saysor offered you a Cash-in-Lieu Payment, you must inform us of your decision to proceed with the repair or replacement, or alternatively accept the Cashin-Lieu Payment, within thirty (30) days | ahs.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 (sample homeowner plan agreement PDF, 2026) |
| Cash instead of repair — Select | Select may pay a cash settlement for an irreparable part; installation not includedWhat the source saysSelect may choose to pay a cash settlement for the irreparable component of the system or appliance. Select is not responsible for installation. | selecthomewarranty.com, checked Nov 18, 2026 |
Related pages
- American Home Shield: what the contract says
- Select Home Warranty: what the contract says
- Home warranty waiting period: when does coverage start?
- Do you pay the home warranty service fee if the claim is denied?
- Home warranty pre-existing condition exclusions explained
- Home warranty coverage limits: how much will they pay?
- How to cancel a home warranty, and what refund you get
- Choice Home Warranty: what the contract says